Choristoneura fumiferana scorecard

2247
Contributor(s):
Impact
SpreadNotesScore
Spread Rate Mostly nursery stock and home garden. Habitat in CA sparse, so spread and establishment should be slow. Can fly or be transported in infested plant material. 3
Spread Amount Balsam fir, white spruce, red spruce, and black spruce are highly preferred. It is unlikely that this pest will become highly established, though it may begin to feed heavily on other conifers. 1
DamageNotesScore
Ecological It is unlikely that this pest will become a serious pest due to the lack of hosts. However, it has attacked other conifers (minimally) ie. Tamarack, pine and hemlock. 0
Agricultural Nursery stock (Balsam fir, white spruce, red spruce, and black spruce are highly preferred). 2
Infrastructure 0
Cultural 0
Health 0
BenefitNotesScore
Ecological 0
Agricultural 0
Infrastructure 0
Cultural 0
Benefit Health 0
Ability to Respond
Ease of ResponseNotesScore
Detection Detection may be achieved through pheromone trapping. 4
Control Chemical control doesn't kill all of the larvae, as they are protected by silk webbing. 3
Tools in PlaceNotesScore
Entry A-rated pest from CDFA. 5
Control A-rated pest from CDFA. 5
Outreach None. 0
Scorecard Totals
Impact Total:
6
[Impact] = ([Spread] + [Damage] - [Benefit])
Ability to Respond Total:
17
[Ability to Respond] = ([Ease of Response] + [Tools in Place])
Confidence
Confidence:  low
Notes:
I am unsure as to why this is CDFA A-rated. There is no natural habitat of its preferred hosts. It may behave very differently in CA than the eastern US (ie. feed on pine) which would affect these ratings.