Phakopsora pachyrhizi scorecard

2312
Impact
SpreadNotesScore
Spread Rate USDA notes that it was carried by wind from South America in 2004. It is now found in 16 US States, plus Gulf coast Mexico. 5
Spread Amount Infects legumes, concurbits, kudzu and corn. Wind borne. Requires high humidity, which may help control spread in California interior. 3
DamageNotesScore
Ecological Potential impact to native legumes. Control of pest requires use of fungicides. 3
Agricultural Significant pest of key soybean, bean, corn, and cucumber crops. Reduces yield 10-80% depending on infection level. Devastating if untreated. Affacts Quality 4
Infrastructure 0
Cultural 0
Health 0
BenefitNotesScore
Ecological May act as a natural control for Kudzu 1
Agricultural 0
Infrastructure 0
Cultural 0
Benefit Health 0
Ability to Respond
Ease of ResponseNotesScore
Detection Readily detectable by trained observers. 5
Control Shortages of registered fungicides in CA will make control very difficult if introduced. Easily controlled with fungicides registered elsewhere. 2
Tools in PlaceNotesScore
Entry Strong measures in effect in central U.S. and Gulf Coast. Weaker in West. Windborne spread; no way to prevent it from crossing boundaries and borders, but presently distant. 2
Control Survey for early detection is essential. Limited potential for control if eradication effforts fail. 3
Outreach Well developed outreach in other U.S. areas were developed following introduction and spread. Cloning these efforts would be effective here. National source BMPs, tools, FAQs available. 3
Scorecard Totals
Impact Total:
14
[Impact] = ([Spread] + [Damage] - [Benefit])
Ability to Respond Total:
15
[Ability to Respond] = ([Ease of Response] + [Tools in Place])
Confidence
Confidence:  medium
Notes:
Collaboration of reviewers increased confidence to medium from low